JC Serrano, Founder & CEO of 1000Attorneys.com, a California Bar-Certified Lawyer Referral Service since 2005.
We often receive inquiries from business owners who want advice on how to protect themselves from liability in the event of a truck accident injury lawsuit.
Based on my work with several experienced California truck accident attorneys in our network, here is a breakdown of the key legal risks and what business owners need to know when it comes to minimizing exposure to lawsuits.
What makes employers legally liable in California?
California uses vicarious liability regulations, which suggest that an employer is liable for the actions of its truck drivers, whether or not the employer was negligent. Employers must also consider how drivers are classified, whether employees or independent contractors, for this can dramatically impacts liability.
Without a clear understanding of liability laws, businesses can unknowingly expose themselves to personal injury lawsuits, wrongful death claims and multi-million-dollar settlements.
Understanding Vicarious Liability
Under California’s vicarious liability laws, an employer can be held responsible for truck accident injuries caused by their employees while acting within the course and scope of their employment. This means if a company-owned truck is involved in a crash while making deliveries, transporting materials or conducting business-related activities, the company itself can be sued for damages.
The legal foundation for this rule is “respondeat superior,” which holds that employers are responsible for the negligence of their employees while on the job. In truck accident lawsuits, plaintiffs (injured victims) often pursue legal action against the employer instead of just the driver because companies have deeper pockets and insurance coverage.
When are businesses liable for truck accidents?
In California, an employer could face legal repercussions if:
• The driver was an employee rather than an independent contractor.
• The motorist was engaged in work-related activities when the accident happened.
• There was negligence, including speeding, careless driving and breaking traffic laws.
Employers can also face direct liability if the accident results from poor hiring practices, lack of driver training or failure to maintain company trucks.
Independent Contractors Versus Employees: The Liability Divide
One of the most critical factors in determining employer liability is how the driver is classified—as an employee or an independent contractor.
Employees: Full Employer Liability
If the driver is a W-2 employee, your business is fully liable for any accidents that occur within the course of employment. Therefore:
• You must carry commercial insurance to cover accidents.
• Injured victims can sue both the driver and your company.
• You are responsible for hiring, training and monitoring your drivers.
Independent Contractors: Less Employer Liability
If the driver is an independent contractor, your business can often avoid liability—but not always. While companies generally aren’t liable for the negligence of independent contractors, if a business exerts too much control over how the driver operates, courts may classify the driver as an employee, increasing liability risk.
For example, trucking companies that lease trucks and require strict operational rules can still be held responsible in California courts.
The ABC Test of Employment classification in California (which came into effect with the AB5 law) applies more rigorously to companies that wish to treat truck drivers as independent contractors. If a business controls a driver’s schedule, routes or tasks, the driver becomes an employee, and the company assumes additional risk.
The Hidden Risks Of Employer Negligence
Even if your company is not directly responsible for an accident, you can still be sued for negligence if:
• You hired an unqualified driver without proper background checks.
• The company truck was poorly maintained, leading to a mechanical failure.
• You failed to train your drivers on California trucking laws and safety.
• You pressured drivers to violate federal hours of service (HOS) laws, leading to fatigued driving accidents.
In these cases, businesses can be sued separately from the driver under negligent hiring, supervision or training claims.
How Businesses Can Protect Themselves From Lawsuits
To minimize legal risks and avoid becoming the target of a truck accident lawsuit, businesses should:
• Clearly define employment classification. Ensure drivers meet the legal requirements for independent contractors if they are classified as such.
• Carry the right insurance coverage. Commercial auto insurance and liability policies should be high enough to cover potential injury claims.
• Screen drivers carefully. Conduct thorough background checks, drug testing and safety training for all company drivers.
• Maintain vehicles regularly. Poor truck maintenance is a common factor in truck accident lawsuits; routine inspections help reduce liability risks.
• Follow federal and state regulations. Adhering to California truck safety laws, weight limits and FMCSA rules can be significant factors in helping prevent legal exposure.
Reducing Liability And Knowing Your Rights
I believe it’s important for California business owners across industries to be familiar with employment liability in order to avoid costly lawsuits. Even one serious truck accident can lead to high insurance premiums and coverage disputes, large settlements or jury verdicts, penalties from the government for noncompliance, not to mention damage to your reputation.
California’s vicarious liability and employment classification laws make truck accident lawsuits complex. While truck accident victims must be aware of their legal right to pursue financial compensation from the at-fault parties, business owners should also take proactive measures to shield themselves from liability.
The best defense is prevention—but if an accident occurs, knowing how liability works can make a big difference between a resolved claim and a costly lawsuit.
The information provided here is not legal advice and does not purport to be a substitute for advice of counsel on any specific matter. For legal advice, you should consult with an attorney concerning your specific situation.
Forbes Business Council is the foremost growth and networking organization for business owners and leaders. Do I qualify?
Read the full article here
