Rob De La Espriella is the creator of BlueDragon, a problem-solving system used by the US national laboratories and nuclear facilities.
United States businesses are silently hemorrhaging trillions of dollars through a surprisingly basic shortcoming: our inability to effectively solve recurring human and organizational performance problems.
From healthcare errors to industrial accidents and from procurement inefficiencies to cybersecurity breaches, the financial impact of these recurring issues dramatically affects our national productivity and competitiveness.
The Trillion Dollar Problem Hiding In Plain Sight
Our inability to solve recurring human and organizational problems is a crisis, and the cost of these problems can be staggering.
• Venture capital firms have lost millions due to what I see is often a lack of an in-depth analysis of a company’s operations.
• Government contractors routinely exceed their budgets by millions of dollars due to unaddressed systemic issues.
• The U.S. healthcare system alone loses over $700 billion annually to preventable errors and inefficiencies, with predictions that this could soon reach $1 trillion.
• The cost of poor software quality exceeds $2 trillion per year.
• As a specific example, I’ve directly seen the cost of recurring issues at a multi-unit nuclear power generating station exceed $30 million per year.
When adding up recurring human and organizational problems across all sectors, the total cost is in the trillions. But what makes these costs particularly tragic is that they’re largely preventable. And it’s not because of a lack of technology or resources; it’s our outdated approach to solving those problems.
Why Traditional Problem-Solving Methods Fail
Traditional root cause analysis (RCA) tools were developed in the previous century when work environments were less complex, and they are simply no longer effective. The modern work environment creates a dynamic pressure cooker that complicates the problem-solving process.
After three decades of solving complex problems, four key factors contribute to this problem-solving crisis:
1. Increased complexity: In today’s workplace, humans interface with advanced technology, intricate processes and elaborate organizational structures, creating countless error opportunities.
2. Speed of change: Technological advancement has outpaced operational procedures and training, as well as traditional RCA methodologies.
3. Lack of depth of analysis: Human behaviors are not a root cause, but personnel are consistently blamed for problems without a holistic and in-depth evaluation of the problem.
4. Lack of expertise: Many organizations lack skilled problem-solvers. Attempting to solve complex human and organizational problems without an expert is like going to trial without a trial attorney.
When organizations fail to identify the root causes of their recurring problems, they face both direct costs (financial losses, equipment damage, legal liabilities) and more damaging hidden costs, including reduced productivity, lower morale, higher turnover, missed opportunities, delayed innovations, loss of public trust and decreased stakeholder confidence.
Upskilling Our Way Of Thinking
Modern problem-solving also requires a fundamental shift in the skills and training required. Here are three essential elements of modern problem-solving:
1. Emphasis on critical thinking: Critical thinking is the intellectually disciplined process of gathering and analyzing evidence to generate unbiased, focused questions that will uncover the deepest-seated causes of human and organizational issues.
2. The application of systems theory: Modern problems require a holistic approach that examines how different parts of an organization interact and influence each other (e.g., technical systems, human factors, equipment interfaces and management control systems). Only by understanding these complex interactions can we identify why our systems are producing the results they do— and how to redesign them to achieve desired outcomes.
3. The integration of behavioral analysis: Understanding and addressing human performance factors is crucial. This means analyzing not just what went wrong, but why people made the decisions they did within their organizational context.
Proven Results
Organizations we’ve worked with that adopted a more modern approach to solving recurring problems achieved dramatic results. For example:
• A U.S. government department completed a root cause analysis with six people in six weeks—originally estimated to require 50 people over four to five months—uncovering $148 million in recoverable costs.
• A national laboratory resolved a five-year cybersecurity vulnerability in just four weeks.
• A chemical weapons facility identified the causes of seven recurring motor failures over 11 months that traditional analyses could not solve.
Transforming Our Problem-Solving Culture
To address this potential trillion-dollar drain on our economy, organizations can:
1. Recognize the inadequacy of traditional problem-solving approaches in modern environments. RCA tools developed in the previous century, such as Fishbone diagrams, 5-Whys and Barrier Analysis, are too linear and reductionist to handle today’s complex challenges.
2. Invest in modern RCA methodologies that integrate critical thinking, systems theory and behavioral analysis. Advanced methodologies provide an integrated framework for gathering and analyzing evidence, generating unbiased lines of inquiry and uncovering deep-seated organizational weaknesses.
3. Train the workforce on advanced problem-solving techniques that match the complexity of today’s challenges. This means developing both entry-level analysts who can handle rapid investigations and advanced practitioners capable of solving complex, human-centric problems, as well as training them on the use of artificial intelligence and virtual whiteboards.
4. Create accountability for addressing root causes rather than just symptoms. Leaders must move beyond quick fixes and band-aid solutions to demand thorough analysis and sustainable corrective actions. This includes tracking the true cost of recurring issues.
5. Foster a culture of continuous improvement. This means shifting from a reactive to a proactive stance, conducting regular assessments of organizational defenses and creating an environment where proactively addressing the root causes of human and organizational problems is encouraged and rewarded.
It Takes Courage
The cost of not solving recurring problems isn’t just financial; it’s a drag on American innovation and competitiveness. As we face increasingly complex challenges in artificial intelligence, clean energy and space exploration, our ability to solve complex, human-centric problems becomes even more critical.
The choice is clear: Continue with outdated approaches or embrace modern methodologies that match today’s challenges. The return on investment isn’t just measured in lower operating costs but in improved safety, enhanced innovation and increased global competitiveness.
Modern problem-solving methods and tools exist today. The question is: Does your company have the courage to implement them?
Forbes Business Council is the foremost growth and networking organization for business owners and leaders. Do I qualify?
Read the full article here
