Sam Nelson, President, Downstreet Digital. 15+ years running digital advertising and marketing in the political, public and private sector.
Our team was tasked with solving a critical problem: How to drive voter registration in a competitive landscape where traditional outreach had failed.
The client’s initial attempt at voter registration relied on thousands of dollars in direct mail campaigning. However, the results were underwhelming—only seven people visited the online registration landing page as a result of the outreach. This staggering inefficiency underscored the need for a new approach.
We designed a digital voter registration campaign that leveraged the advanced targeting capabilities of social media. After a two-month trial period, the results of our digital voter registration campaign exceeded expectations, driving thousands of unique users to the registration page, all under budget.
This approach can be applied across industries. Whether you’re a nonprofit looking to drive donations, a retail business aiming to increase sales or a service provider seeking new leads, the same principles apply: strategic targeting, message testing and real-time optimization.
Key Takeaways For Business Leaders
1. Advanced Audience Segmentation
To ensure efficiency, we excluded existing voter files and instead used behavioral and demographic data to identify individuals who were likely unregistered but ideologically aligned with our target audience. This process involved analyzing behaviors, segmenting audiences and refining these groups further through testing.
In translating this strategy for businesses, this means:
• Using customer data to identify high-intent buyers.
• Excluding audiences who are unlikely to convert (e.g., existing customers for acquisition campaigns).
• Refining targeting based on real-time engagement metrics.
By focusing on high-potential audiences, businesses can avoid wasting resources on individuals who are unlikely to engage, thereby increasing efficiency and ROI.
2. Message And Creative Testing
A key advantage of digital marketing is the ability to test different messages rapidly and at scale. We conducted multiple rounds of A/B testing, evaluating:
• Various calls to action (e.g., “Register to Vote Today” versus “Make Your Voice Heard in the Next Election”).
• Different visual styles and ad formats (e.g., images versus videos, direct messaging versus storytelling).
• Issue-based messaging that appealed to specific audience concerns.
Business leaders can adopt a similar approach by:
• Testing different headlines, visuals and offers in their ad campaigns.
• Running 36- to 48-hour test cycles to optimize content before scaling.
• Allocating more budget to high-performing creatives while discontinuing underperforming ads.
3. Cost-Effective Budget Optimization
Rather than setting a static budget for each ad, we continuously adjusted spending based on performance by increasing spending on high-performing ads to maximize reach, pausing ads that showed signs of declining engagement and retargeting individuals who interacted with the ads but hadn’t yet completed the registration process.
As a part of a larger strategy, this means ensuring every dollar spent contributes to meaningful engagement. Whether running paid search ads, social media campaigns or programmatic advertising, continuous budget reallocation can help maximize efficiency.
4. Retargeting And Social Accountability
One of the most effective aspects of the campaign was the use of social accountability messaging. Toward the later stages, we introduced peer influence messaging, such as “Over one-third of residents in your county are not registered to vote” and “If you’re seeing this ad, chances are you’re not registered. Take 30 seconds to fix that now.”
Businesses can apply this type of social accountability by:
• Implementing retargeting pixels to track users who visited a website but didn’t convert.
• Using social proof (e.g., testimonials, user reviews, influencer endorsements) to build credibility.
• Creating urgency with messaging like: “Join 10,000 customers who have already switched to our service.”
Integrating Digital And Traditional Marketing For Maximum Impact
While digital advertising can outperform traditional methods, I don’t think this means businesses have to abandon traditional strategies altogether. Instead, a multi-channel approach can create a more cohesive marketing plan. Here are some ideas how businesses can integrate digital with traditional marketing:
• Direct mail and digital: Send a physical mailer with a QR code that leads to a landing page with a targeted digital offer.
• TV and social media ads: Reinforce TV commercials with highly targeted Facebook and Instagram ads to reach viewers who engage with the content online.
• Events and retargeting: Capture leads at in-person events and retarget them with online ads to nurture engagement.
By blending digital and traditional methods, businesses can create seamless customer journeys that maximize reach and engagement.
Continuous Optimization Is Essential
As touched on in an earlier section on creative testing, rather than running static ads, it’s important to continuously test and refine your messaging. By identifying top-performing ads early and adjusting your budget accordingly, you can maximize engagement while keeping costs low.
To help with this, look to use analytics tools to track ad performance, set up automated rules to adjust budgets based on engagement and regularly refresh creatives to prevent ad fatigue.
Amplifying Social Proof For Greater Impact
Retargeting and social proof can also play a crucial role in our campaign’s success. Businesses can leverage this concept by:
• Encouraging satisfied customers to leave reviews on platforms like Google and Yelp.
• Highlighting customer success stories in marketing materials.
• Using influencer partnerships to build credibility and expand reach.
Ideological And Behavioral Targeting For Business Success
By focusing on behavioral data and issue-based messaging, we ensured that our outreach efforts resonated with the audience most likely to take action. Toward replicating this approach, make sure to:
• Conduct audience research to understand customer motivations.
• Segment customers based on interests, purchasing behavior and engagement history.
• Create tailored messaging that speaks directly to customer pain points and aspirations.
Scaling This Approach For Greater Impact
By refining audience segmentation, message testing and budget optimization strategies, businesses can achieve greater efficiency and engagement—even in industries where traditional marketing is still dominant.
The key to success lies in strategic execution, continuous optimization and an unwavering commitment to reaching the right audience with the right message at the right time.
Forbes Business Council is the foremost growth and networking organization for business owners and leaders. Do I qualify?
Read the full article here
