Tim Pratte, CEO of Selerix.
For years, brokers have been the quarterbacks of employee benefits—navigating the complex playbook of insurance plans, renewal meetings and employer expectations. But that game has changed. And not unlike the Patriots’ post-Brady offense, some brokers are struggling to keep up.
Employers don’t just want help picking a health plan. They want a strategic partner who understands their business, helps navigate compliance and delivers seamless benefits technology. The good news is that brokers have been training for this, and they have the resources at their fingertips to evolve their value proposition and complete the play.
The Traditional Broker Model Is Under Pressure
For anyone still operating on a “meet once a year, present plan options, and call it a day” model, here’s why that approach is on its last legs.
1. Employers Expect More Than Just Rate Shopping
HR leaders need more than pricing. They want a benefits strategy that attracts and retains talent. They need help aligning benefits with business goals, ensuring compliance and educating employees throughout the year.
If you’re not delivering that level of support, someone else will. According to LIMRA, 77% of employers now expect to rely more on their broker to provide benefits administration and technology guidance—not just insurance recommendations. The role of the broker isn’t shrinking; it’s expanding.
2. Compliance Is A Growing Headache For Employers
Is keeping up with ACA filings, COBRA regulations and state-mandated leave programs a priority for you? Probably not, but it should be because it is for the employers you serve. Compliance mistakes can be costly for them, and it’s a pain they feel you can help with—by connecting them with the right vendors and services.
Compliance right now is a shifting target, so employers need advisors and experts who can help them meet and anticipate ACA reporting requirements. If you aren’t proactively helping clients stay ahead of their regulatory changes, you’re missing an opportunity to build that relationship.
3. The Market Is More Competitive Than Ever
Brokers aren’t just competing with other brokers anymore. Large firms are leveraging built-in technology and compliance expertise to gain an edge. Meanwhile, tech-driven platforms are cutting brokers out of the equation, offering direct-to-employer benefits administration solutions.
According to Precedence Research, the employee benefits broker market will grow from $45.69 billion in 2024 to around $78.21 billion by 2034. That means more competition, more pressure and more consolidation. Employers aren’t just looking for a broker anymore. They want a strategic partner—someone who brings real solutions and not just a menu of health plans.
Data, Analytics And Integrated Technology Are Now Table Stakes
The brokers winning today have changed the way they partner with clients and are using data, analytics and technology to help companies make smarter benefits decisions.
I believe all of these should be on your radar and part of the services you offer and advise on:
Data-Driven Decision Making
Employers want to see the numbers—how benefits impact retention, what plans employees are actually using and where they can optimize costs. Brokers who bring claims analytics, plan utilization reports and workforce trends to the table are guiding strategy—not just selling benefits.
Integrated Benefits Technology
Disconnected HR systems can create more problems than they solve. If benefits administration doesn’t integrate with payroll, HRIS and compliance tracking, employers often end up with more manual work, errors and frustration.
Brokers who help clients choose, implement and optimize benefits tech become irreplaceable. If you’re not offering guidance on seamless, tech-driven benefits administration, you’re leaving money on the table.
Enhanced Client Reporting
Employers don’t just want a benefits package—they want proof that it’s delivering value. Brokers who provide clear, real-time insights on cost savings, engagement and compliance risks win long-term trust.
Bottom line? Employers expect data, automation and seamless integration. If you ignore that shift or have nothing to say about it, you likely won’t stay relevant for long.
How To Stay Indispensable As A Broker
If you want to survive and thrive, I urge you to stop thinking of yourself as just an insurance vendor and start acting like the strategic partner employers actually need. Saying, “This plan is a great option,” is one thing. Proving it with data is what sets great brokers apart from the riff-raff.
Master Compliance Before It Masters You
Employers don’t have time to track every change in ACA, COBRA and state-mandated leave laws—and they shouldn’t have to. Brokers who stay ahead of the regulatory landscape and provide proactive guidance will build deeper trust and keep clients from looking elsewhere. If compliance only comes up after there’s already a problem, you’re too late.
Get Smart On Benefits Tech
Disconnected systems, manual processes and complicated enrollments frustrate employers and employees alike. Brokers who help clients streamline their benefits administration platforms—making sure they integrate with payroll and HR systems and are aligned with the employer’s financial and HR goals—will lock in long-term relationships.
Show Up More Than Once A Year
The best brokers aren’t seasonal. Benefits strategy doesn’t stop after open enrollment, and brokers who provide ongoing education, proactive plan optimization and year-round compliance support will outshine the competition.
Deliver Data, Not Just Promises
Employers want to know their benefits are working. Brokers who use claims analytics, employee utilization data and financial impact reports to guide benefits decisions earn trust—and renewals.
Evolve Or Be Replaced
The role of benefits brokers is certainly not disappearing. But it is changing crazy fast. When employers engage with brokers, they’re not just looking to you to negotiate insurance rates. They need a compliance expert, a technology advisor and a year-round strategic partner.
Brokers who embrace technology, provide data-driven insights and integrate compliance expertise will thrive. Those who stick to a transactional, outdated model will be replaced—by tech-driven competitors or by brokers who simply do it better.
It is the brokers who invest in the right strategies, tools and partnerships today who will really define the future of this industry.
So the only question left is: Will you be leading this change or scrambling to keep up?
Forbes Business Council is the foremost growth and networking organization for business owners and leaders. Do I qualify?
Read the full article here
